Pro
August 1, 2017
When Netflix released 13 Reasons Why, it seemed like everyone had an opinion about it. Some loved it, some hated it. What was undeniable was that it sparked some serious controversy.
Many of the negative reviews (including reviews by Mark Henick of CNN and Daniel D’Addario of Time Magazine) asserted that the show was glamorizing suicide. After reading some of these reviews and hearing about the show from my friends, I decided to see for myself. I binge watched all thirteen episodes in a week, and I found myself agreeing much more with the positive reviews than the negative ones. I personally loved the rawness and relatability of the show. It actually addressed real issues that affect teenagers everyday.
Now, I do understand where the outrage is coming from. I know it is very uncommon for a show to focus so specifically on such a grim issue. But to be completely honest, suicide is something that needs to be talked about. The show does not glamorize suicide; it tries to show the long-term effects of it. Hannah (Katherine Langford)’s suicide takes its toll on all the characters. Whether it’s her parents, her classmate Clay (Dylan Minnette), or even someone she barely knew, this series allows its viewers to understand the immense effect suicide can have on a community.
There are many who feel that people should not watch this show, as they feel it encourages suicide. While I understand this concern, I feel the show can be a way for people to see that they are not alone. The series spreads awareness and conveys realistic scenes that are relatable to many viewers.
One criticism that I very outwardly disagree with is the assessment that there are no trigger warnings about the topics discussed and shown throughout the show. This is not true. The producers made sure to give a disclaimer before particularly graphic episodes, explaining that the episode contains scenes that viewers may find disturbing. For example in episode 12, a disclaimer is ran before the show begins. This makes sure that those who do not want to be exposed to sexual assault are aware of what they are about to see.
One thing that cemented my appreciation for this show was the outreach of the cast and crew. Many of them have posted videos on social media talking about the importance of reaching out for help before you get to the point where it’s too late. For example, Netflix released a 30 minute episode called 13 Reasons Why: Beyond the Reasons where the cast, producers, and mental health professionals discussed scenes dealing with difficult issues, such as bullying, depression, and sexual assault. That is what is special about this show. The cast conveys a sense of realness. They took it upon themselves to help others who may be going through similar circumstances.
The cast does not just excel on social media, though. They are excellent in the show itself. I loved how connected I felt to the actors. Most of them were relatively unknown before this show. Alisha Boe, who plays Jessica, stood out to me the most. Her acting adds a bit of raw vulnerability to the show without making her seem like solely a victim. It’s not just Boe, however. None of the characters are one dimensional. They all show the different sides to their characters, adding so much more depth to the show.
In the novel version of 13 Reasons Why, Hannah Baker said, “You don’t know what goes on in anyone’s life but your own. And when you mess with one part of a person’s life, you’re not messing with just that part. Unfortunately, you can’t be that precise and selective. When you mess with one part of a person’s life, you’re messing with their entire life.” Personally, I learned a lot from watching this show. It showed me how much my words and actions can affect others around me.
Yes, 13 Reasons Why is controversial. Yes, it discusses some very heavy subject matter. But you should still watch it, because it will teach you what effect your actions can truly have.
Casey Giszczak • Nov 3, 2017 at 8:46 am
Hi my name is Casey, I am in Miss Hammitt’s 7th hour Literary Genres class. I think your article was really well written, especially over a topic that some people might not like. I have seen the show, and I agree with what you wrote about how suicide is an issue that no one really talks about. I think you did a great job explaining why this is something that happens a lot with teens and how they can relate to the show. Your article shows another perspective that people might not think about, and I think you did a really nice job with that.
Liza Kaya • Nov 2, 2017 at 7:07 pm
I think this article is well written. I have also watched this show and I would agree with everything the writer has to say. The show teaches you lot about life and that you never know whats happening in other peoples life. This article is a very good explanation of the show.